|Full name||Alfie McNaulty|
|Cause of death||Punctured brain|
(stab wound to the eye)
|Residence||Pacific Bay, U.S.|
Jewel thief (formerly)
|Appears in||Criminal Case|
|First appeared||Case #51: Killer Takes All (s2)|
Alfie was a croupier of the "Mennagio Casino" in Paradise City and a former jewel thief. He has neat black hair and blue eyes covered by a kelly green visor. At the time of his death, he wore a forest green croupier uniform.
Alfie was found outside the Paradise City casino strip with a croupier stick jammed into his eye. On the scene, Frank confirmed the croupier stick was used as the murder weapon. Further analysis from Roxie indicated that the stick skewered his brain, killing him instantly. She managed to find residue on the stick that turned out to be from a shrimp cocktail. This meant that Alfie's killer ate shrimp cocktails.
Killer and motives
The killer turned out to be professional gambler Grace O'Brien.
Grace recalled the days when Alfie and herself were once partners in crime, stealing jewelry from Pacific Bay's most expensive jewelry stores, but things have changed since Alfie became a reformed croupier in Paradise City. Grace politely asked Alfie to rob the jewelry shop of the Mennagio Casino, but showing signs of reformation, Alfie could not afford to risk his career as a croupier and refused. Grace had to commit the robbery on her own, but Alfie attempted to stop Grace's jewelry heist by reporting her to the Paradise City authorities. Grace could not afford to let Alfie get underneath her skin, so to remove whom she viewed as a double-crosser, Grace played a game of poker or two at Alfie's section. During the game, Grace ate a shrimp platter or two and wrote a note on the empty plate, asking Alfie to meet Grace outside. The plan went perfectly when Grace saw Alfie outside the casino, knocked the reformed croupier off-balance and took his croupier stick away from him. Grace then slid the hilt violently on Alfie's left eye, killing him. Unfortunately, the player proved to be luckier than Grace as the player's investigative skills proved to be too much for the professional gambler to bear, so Grace was required to attend trial for her crimes.
Grace tried to sweet-talk Judge Dante into playing a game of poker to avoid indictment, but the Judge abstained to gamble knowing how risky gambling is, so he made this message clear: 20 years in jail for the murder of the reformed croupier. Judge Dante's verdict angered Grace, but handing out sentences for murder is the game the Judge was really good in. Frank felt that the player wanted to gamble following the indictment, although the player personally felt that they have more productive motives in Paradise City than to have fun.